An instructive interview with Dean Baker, co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research, on Salon yesterday:
“But it’s not just conservatives who are saying that the system is broken. Even in states with Democratic governors like California and New York, people like Jerry Brown and Andrew Cuomo are talking about reforming pension fund benefits. If the long-term problem is as manageable as you say it is, where did things get off track?
“Well, there are several issues here. A lot of states did not properly budget. In New Jersey, for example, it almost became a joke that they weren’t paying their pension contributions. So they really do have a serious issue of underfunding — no doubt about it. So, yes, you do have cases where states do have underfunded pensions, which are going to be a big liability. And it was irresponsibility on the part of the legislatures and governors to let that happen.
“The other part of the story is that you have these sort of poster children where this or that person has retired at age 51 with a six-figure pension. Now they are the exception — we know that, because we have data on average pensions and they are pretty low in almost every case. In Wisconsin I think the average pension is $24,000 or $25,000, and you’d be pretty hard-pressed to say that’s lavish. Bu there are certainly outlying cases, and I myself would think it’s a good idea to change those. You probably don’t want to have people retiring under the age of 60. Maybe police and fire might be an exception, but there probably aren’t a lot of positions where you want people to be able to retire at these very young ages and be able to get full pensions. So I could certainly understand changing that. But the principle of the defined benefit pension, I think, still makes a lot of sense. And the fact that states are in a position to give it to their workers at very little cost — again, assuming proper budgeting — is not a bad thing.”
I’m all for states taking steps to correct these shortfalls. My question is: why are the workers, by themselves, consistently asked to make up the whole difference? Whenever conservatives talk about ‘shared sacrifice,’ it’s a good idea to keep a hand on your wallet – they’re not remotely interested in reaching for theirs’.
http://www.salon.com/news/budget_showdown/index.html?story=/tech/htww/2011/03/03/dean_baker_and_the_pension_crisis_part_2